Scroll to top of page

What does media buying in-housing mean for the future of agencies? Part 1

It is no secret that the digital revolution is completely transforming the role of media agencies, since Search or programmaticprogrammaticProgrammatic advertising refers to the automated buying and selling of ad spaces; most of the time, it takes place in real time through platforms such as ad exchanges, DSPs and SSPs.Learn more campaigns are not managed the same way as TV or print budgets were in the past. This shift also affects media buying!
Faced with this new order, in-housing has emerged as a fitting solution for a growing number of advertisers and despite being an established trend, it remains little-discussed. fifty-five’s Pierre Harand, Managing Director France, volunteered to share some tips for responding to the most frequently asked questions for advertisers.

Where does this trend come from?

From the data, of course! The trend of advertisers in-housing media buying is closely linked to the digital revolution and the way it transforms companies. Most pure players internalised their digital media buying long ago. As advertisers have swapped out their traditional practices for more digital-friendly solutions, it is no surprise that they are adapting the same media buying organisation as pure players, including in-housing.

Digital media is changing the way we interact, consume, and stay informed, which means that marketers must change the way they reach their audiences. The digital transformation is moving through sectors one by one, with early adopters on the frontlines for change: tourism, media, and retail. Others will soon follow, including telecommunications, automotive, and banking. Advertisers’ traditional business models have been upended, as has their way of serving and communicating with clients.

In this context, data is the key resource when it comes to rethinking a relevant marketing plan – particularly for advertising campaigns.
While data was initially carelessly treated in a silosiloThe concept of silo refers to the organisation of a company whose different departments do not (or barely) communicate, which harms information sharing. Learn more, it has become the core subject of client strategies and is the catalyst of wider-scale digital transformation in businesses.

Therefore, data can be best exploited through advertising campaigns from inside organisations (and not from outside). To properly manage efficient digital ad campaigns – that is to say, to give data its due primary role – you must be able to work closely with e-commerce, CRMCRMCRM (Customer Relationship Management) refers to the methods, services and tools implemented to maintain and improve the quality of a brand's relationship with its customers.Learn more, Data (perhaps also DMPDMPDMPs (Data Management Platforms) are platforms that centralise and aggregate all data related to a brand's campaigns and customers.Learn more), and IS teams.

Advertisers are thus willing to take back their digital strategy, as they become conscious of data’s enormous value - which calls the roles of media agencies into question.

Why doesn’t the traditional media agency model work anymore?

The role of media agencies is also evolving.

Of course, managing digital campaigns presents different stakes than classic advertising levers, and it has taken time for traditional agencies to adapt to the advent of programmaticprogrammaticProgrammatic advertising refers to the automated buying and selling of ad spaces; most of the time, it takes place in real time through platforms such as ad exchanges, DSPs and SSPs.Learn more media buying, and to develop the required technical expertise.

But above all else, the role of media agencies is problematic because of their history, and generally-accepted remuneration policies. The job was created at a time when managing advertising spaces (TV, print, OOH, radio) was based on negotiating large volumes. Historically, agencies were paid based on a percentage of the media budget invested, since, logically, a larger budget meant more negotiations with each advertising network. However, programmatic advertising means that this exercise can be largely automated. Thus, a higher budget does not necessarily increase an agency’s workload, and the historic fees model may no longer be relevant.

What’s more, services provided by media agencies come in a three-part bundle: managing campaign media buying, driving media strategy and performance, and providing the relevant tools. However, this remuneration model skews towards the media plan and leads to non-transparent business practices, particularly given the structure of costs and potential conflicts of interest for agencies (including intermediaries and hidden margins, negotiation of technical fees, retroactive commissions...). This was recently pointed out in reports published by the Association of National Advertisers in the US.

Lastly, the way in which ad serving tools (such as DoubleClick or Sizmek) are contracted is also problematic. In controlling advertising tools, media agencies are contractual owners of the respective data. Advertisers, who nevertheless pay non-negligible amounts to communicate through their clients, are not completely free to capitalise upon and exploit the data – especially because changing media agency might mean losing a given digital ad communication’s history. Is this kind of dependence sustainable in a world where data has taken on a strategic value for businesses?

What’s next for agencies?

Media buying internalisation is not widely discussed, because traditional media agencies are, understandably, ill at ease with the subject. At fifty-five, we don’t believe that internalisation means the end of agencies. Au contraire, it signals a metamorphosis, with agencies changing their role to provide more consulting and support to advertisers. Ultimately, the goal is to change the way brands benefit from agency expertise, which will lead to changes in the way they operate and are remunerated.

One benefit of this trend is that the black box mentality that drives the advertiser/agency relationship will be no more, which will result in greater transparency, empowerment, and trust.

_

Want to learn more about media-buy in-housing?
Check the second part of this interview: Is in-housing media buying a miracle cure?

Translated from the original French by Niamh Cloughley.

Want to learn more? Get in touch!

31-08-2017

close legal

À propos

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Donec a venenatis dolor, non ornare ligula. Nam ultricies elementum tellus, sed pulvinar libero egestas nec. Fusce facilisis nulla vestibulum, commodo neque eget, dapibus lacus. Aliquam neque felis, sagittis nec consequat sed, commodo ac ipsum. Sed neque tortor, semper quis viverra et, malesuada et eros. Donec at dui ut ligula pharetra aliquet. Etiam dapibus semper orci. Integer efficitur dolor tortor, nec mattis elit placerat vel. Ut nulla enim, lacinia in pharetra id, convallis vitae massa. Donec neque est, tincidunt non ullamcorper commodo, tincidunt non turpis. Pellentesque viverra enim a sapien placerat, ut volutpat mauris condimentum. Proin tincidunt sollicitudin dui, sit amet condimentum ante commodo a. Aenean posuere aliquam purus, sed aliquam magna sagittis finibus. Morbi molestie feugiat feugiat. Phasellus tempus in dolor vel maximus. Cras efficitur sagittis lorem porta iaculis. Maecenas sed hendrerit urna. In mattis posuere purus, sit amet placerat arcu posuere quis. Etiam nec arcu nec magna interdum maximus. Integer sit amet lacus neque. Curabitur interdum molestie magna, in scelerisque tellus iaculis sed. Sed nec metus ut purus efficitur laoreet a quis eros. Proin dui dui, dignissim eget risus sit amet, bibendum condimentum velit. Maecenas in justo eu elit eleifend consectetur. Aenean scelerisque fringilla sollicitudin. Nam sem nibh, pharetra nec lacus non, mollis interdum odio. Aliquam sollicitudin posuere nibh sed eleifend.

Édition

55 SAS, 5 — 7 rue d'Athènes

75009 Paris

+33 1 76 21 91 37

Hébergement

OVH SAS

2, rue Kellermann

59100 Roubaix

+33 8 20 69 87 65

Publication

Lan Anh Vu Hong

Crédits photo

Mats Carduner, Adobe Stock & Unsplash

Vous avez aimé nos nouvelles fraîches sur l'état du marché brandtech ? Inscrivez vous à notre newsletter